RightDataUSA


Vote Data for HR4170 (98th Congress)


Date: November 17, 1983

Subject: Rostenkowski "Gag Rule"

Description: Adoption of the rule providing for House floor consideration of the bill to raise $8 billion in revenues over fiscal 1984-86 through a variety of changes in tax law. The main elements of the bill dealt with mortgage revenue bonds, industrial development bonds, fringe benefits, tax simplification, curbs on sales/lease-back schemes by non-profit groups and the taxation of life insurance companies. The bill also made substantial savings in the Medicare program and revised administration of the Social Security Disability Insurance program. This rule would have allowed debate on numerous tax increases, including a "cap" on the third year of the 1981 tax cuts.

Result: Rejected, 204-214

Names ordered: By yea/nay       Order alphabetically       Order by party       Order by state

Click on a Representative's name to see more information for that Representative.

Voted in Favor:

Gary Ackerman (D-NY)  
Joseph Addabbo (D-NY)  
Daniel Akaka (D-HI)  
Bill Alexander (D-AR)  
Ike Andrews (D-NC)  
Mike Andrews (D-TX)  
Frank Annunzio (D-IL)  
Beryl Anthony (D-AR)  
Doug Applegate (D-OH)  
Les Aspin (D-WI)  
Michael Barnes (D-MD)  
Jim Bates (D-CA)  
Tony Beilenson (D-CA)  
Charles Bennett (D-FL)  
Howard Berman (D-CA)  
Tom Bevill (D-AL)  
Mike Bilirakis (R-FL)  
Edward Boland (D-MA)  
David Bonior (D-MI)  
Don Bonker (D-WA)  
Robert Borski (D-PA)  
Douglas Bosco (D-CA)  
Barbara Boxer (D-CA)  
Robin Britt (D-NC)  
George Brown (D-CA)  
John Bryant (D-TX)  
Sala Burton (D-CA)  
Bill Chappell (D-FL)  
James Clarke (D-NC)  
Tony Coelho (D-CA)  
Ron Coleman (D-TX)  
Barber Conable (R-NY)  
John Conyers (D-MI)  
Jim Cooper (D-TN)  
William Coyne (D-PA)  
George Crockett (D-MI)  
Kika de la Garza (D-TX)  
Ron Dellums (D-CA)  
Butler Derrick (D-SC)  
Norm Dicks (D-WA)  
John Dingell (D-MI)  
Julian Dixon (D-CA)  
Brian Donnelly (D-MA)  
Thomas Downey (D-NY)  
John Duncan (R-TN)  
Richard Durbin (D-IL)  
Bernard Dwyer (D-NJ)  
Dennis Eckart (D-OH)  
Bob Edgar (D-PA)  
Don Edwards (D-CA)  
Lane Evans (D-IL)  
Dante Fascell (D-FL)  
Vic Fazio (D-CA)  
Edward Feighan (D-OH)  
Geraldine Ferraro (D-NY)  
Ronnie Flippo (D-AL)  
Jim Florio (D-NJ)  
Thomas Foglietta (D-PA)  
Tom Foley (D-WA)  
Harold Ford (D-TN)  
William Ford (D-MI)  
Wyche Fowler (D-GA)  
Barney Frank (D-MA)  
Bill Frenzel (R-MN)  
Robert Garcia (D-NY)  
Joe Gaydos (D-PA)  
Sam Gejdenson (D-CT)  
Dick Gephardt (D-MO)  
Sam Gibbons (D-FL)  
Dan Glickman (D-KS)  
William Gray (D-PA)  
Frank Guarini (D-NJ)  
Katie Hall (D-IN)  
Sam Hall (D-TX)  
Tony Hall (D-OH)  
Lee Hamilton (D-IN)  
Frank Harrison (D-PA)  
Charles Hatcher (D-GA)  
Charles Hayes (D-IL)  
Bill Hefner (D-NC)  
Cecil Heftel (D-HI)  
Dennis Hertel (D-MI)  
James Howard (D-NJ)  
Steny Hoyer (D-MD)  
William Hughes (D-NJ)  
Andy Jacobs, Jr. (D-IN)  
Nancy Johnson (R-CT)  
Jim Jones (D-OK)  
Marcy Kaptur (D-OH)  
Robert Kastenmeier (D-WI)  
Barbara Kennelly (D-CT)  
Dale Kildee (D-MI)  
Ray Kogovsek (D-CO)  
Joe Kolter (D-PA)  
Peter Kostmayer (D-PA)  
John LaFalce (D-NY)  
Tom Lantos (D-CA)  
Richard Lehman (D-CA)  
William Lehman (D-FL)  
Mickey Leland (D-TX)  
Mel Levine (D-CA)  
Sander Levin (D-MI)  
Elliott Levitas (D-GA)  
Tom Lewis (R-FL)  
William Lipinski (D-IL)  
Clarence Long (D-MD)  
Gillis Long (D-LA)  
Mike Lowry (D-WA)  
Thomas Luken (D-OH)  
Buddy MacKay (D-FL)  
Ed Markey (D-MA)  
Marty Martinez (D-CA)  
Robert Matsui (D-CA)  
Nicholas Mavroules (D-MA)  
Romano Mazzoli (D-KY)  
Frank McCloskey (D-IN)  
Dave McCurdy (D-OK)  
Matthew McHugh (D-NY)  
Jim McNulty (D-AZ)  
George Miller (D-CA)  
Norman Mineta (D-CA)  
Joseph Minish (D-NJ)  
Parren Mitchell (D-MD)  
Joe Moakley (D-MA)  
Alan Mollohan (D-WV)  
Jim Moody (D-WI)  
Henson Moore (R-LA)  
Bruce Morrison (D-CT)  
Robert Mrazek (D-NY)  
Austin Murphy (D-PA)  
John Murtha (D-PA)  
Steven Neal (D-NC)  
Bill Nelson (D-FL)  
Henry Nowak (D-NY)  
Mary Rose Oakar (D-OH)  
David Obey (D-WI)  
Jim Olin (D-VA)  
Solomon Ortiz (D-TX)  
Richard Ottinger (D-NY)  
Major Owens (D-NY)  
Leon Panetta (D-CA)  
Jerry Patterson (D-CA)  
Don Pease (D-OH)  
Tim Penny (D-MN)  
Claude Pepper (D-FL)  
Tom Petri (R-WI)  
Jake Pickle (D-TX)  
Melvin Price (D-IL)  
Jimmy Quillen (R-TN)  
Nick Rahall (D-WV)  
Charles Rangel (D-NY)  
William Ratchford (D-CT)  
Harry Reid (D-NV)  
Peter Rodino (D-NJ)  
Robert Roe (D-NJ)  
Charlie Rose (D-NC)  
Dan Rostenkowski (D-IL)  
Marge Roukema (R-NJ)  
Edward Roybal (D-CA)  
Marty Russo (D-IL)  
Martin Sabo (D-MN)  
Gus Savage (D-IL)  
James Scheuer (D-NY)  
Charles Schumer (D-NY)  
John Seiberling (D-OH)  
James Shannon (D-MA)  
Phil Sharp (D-IN)  
Gerry Sikorski (D-MN)  
Norman Sisisky (D-VA)  
Jim Slattery (D-KS)  
Larry Smith (D-FL)  
John Spratt (D-SC)  
Harley Staggers, Jr. (D-WV)  
Pete Stark (D-CA)  
Fernand St. Germain (D-RI)  
Louis Stokes (D-OH)  
Samuel Stratton (D-NY)  
Gerry Studds (D-MA)  
Don Sundquist (R-TN)  
Al Swift (D-WA)  
Esteban Torres (D-CA)  
Robert Torricelli (D-NJ)  
Edolphus Towns (D-NY)  
Bob Traxler (D-MI)  
Morris Udall (D-AZ)  
Tim Valentine (D-NC)  
Guy Vander Jagt (R-MI)  
Bruce Vento (D-MN)  
Harold Volkmer (D-MO)  
Doug Walgren (D-PA)  
Henry Waxman (D-CA)  
Ted Weiss (D-NY)  
Alan Wheat (D-MO)  
Charlie Whitley (D-NC)  
Pat Williams (D-MT)  
Charlie Wilson (D-TX)  
Tim Wirth (D-CO)  
Bob Wise (D-WV)  
Howard Wolpe (D-MI)  
Jim Wright (D-TX)  
Chalmers Wylie (R-OH)  
Sidney Yates (D-IL)  
Gus Yatron (D-PA)  
Clement Zablocki (D-WI)  

Voted Against:

Don Albosta (D-MI)  
Glenn Anderson (D-CA)  
Bill Archer (R-TX)  
Les AuCoin (D-OR)  
Robert Badham (R-CA)  
Doug Barnard (D-GA)  
Steve Bartlett (R-TX)  
Herb Bateman (R-VA)  
Berkley Bedell (D-IA)  
Doug Bereuter (R-NE)  
Ed Bethune (R-AR)  
Mario Biaggi (D-NY)  
Thomas Bliley (R-VA)  
Sherwood Boehlert (R-NY)  
Lindy Boggs (D-LA)  
Bill Boner (D-TN)  
Rick Boucher (D-VA)  
John Breaux (D-LA)  
Jack Brooks (D-TX)  
William Broomfield (R-MI)  
Hank Brown (R-CO)  
Jim Broyhill (R-NC)  
Dan Burton (R-IN)  
Beverly Byron (D-MD)  
Carroll Campbell (R-SC)  
William Carney (R-NY)  
Tom Carper (D-DE)  
Bob Carr (D-MI)  
Rod Chandler (R-WA)  
Gene Chappie (R-CA)  
Dick Cheney (R-WY)  
Bill Clinger (R-PA)  
Dan Coats (R-IN)  
Tom Coleman (R-MO)  
Silvio Conte (R-MA)  
Tom Corcoran (R-IL)  
Lawrence Coughlin (R-PA)  
Jim Courter (R-NJ)  
Larry Craig (R-ID)  
Daniel Crane (R-IL)  
Phil Crane (R-IL)  
Norman D'Amours (D-NH)  
Dan Daniel (D-VA)  
William Dannemeyer (R-CA)  
Buddy Darden (D-GA)  
Tom Daschle (D-SD)  
Hal Daub (R-NE)  
Robert Davis (R-MI)  
Mike DeWine (R-OH)  
Bill Dickinson (R-AL)  
David Dreier (R-CA)  
Roy Dyson (D-MD)  
Joseph Early (D-MA)  
Jack Edwards (R-AL)  
Mickey Edwards (R-OK)  
Bill Emerson (R-MO)  
Glenn English (D-OK)  
Ben Erdreich (D-AL)  
John Erlenborn (R-IL)  
Cooper Evans (R-IA)  
Bobbi Fiedler (R-CA)  
Jack Fields (R-TX)  
Hamilton Fish, Jr. (R-NY)  
Edwin Forsythe (R-NJ)  
Webb Franklin (R-MS)  
Martin Frost (D-TX)  
Don Fuqua (D-FL)  
George Gekas (R-PA)  
Benjamin Gilman (R-NY)  
Newt Gingrich (R-GA)  
Henry B. Gonzalez (D-TX)  
Bill Goodling (R-PA)  
Albert Gore, Jr. (D-TN)  
Bill Gradison (R-OH)  
Phil Gramm (R-TX)  
Bill Green (R-NY)  
Judd Gregg (R-NH)  
Steve Gunderson (R-WI)  
Ralph Hall (D-TX)  
J.P. Hammerschmidt (R-AR)  
George Hansen (R-ID)  
Tom Harkin (D-IA)  
Thomas Hartnett (R-SC)  
Jack Hightower (D-TX)  
John Hiler (R-IN)  
Elwood Hillis (R-IN)  
Marjorie Holt (R-MD)  
Larry Hopkins (R-KY)  
Frank Horton (R-NY)  
Carroll Hubbard (D-KY)  
Jerry Huckaby (D-LA)  
Duncan Hunter (R-CA)  
Earl Hutto (D-FL)  
Henry Hyde (R-IL)  
Andy Ireland (D-FL)  
Jim Jeffords (R-VT)  
Ed Jones (D-TN)  
Walter Jones (D-NC)  
John Kasich (R-OH)  
Abraham Kazen (D-TX)  
Thomas Kindness (R-OH)  
Ken Kramer (R-CO)  
Robert Lagomarsino (R-CA)  
Delbert Latta (R-OH)  
Marvin Leath (D-TX)  
Norman Lent (R-NY)  
Bob Livingston (R-LA)  
Marilyn Lloyd (D-TN)  
Tom Loeffler (R-TX)  
Trent Lott (R-MS)  
Bill Lowery (R-CA)  
Manuel Lujan (R-NM)  
Stan Lundine (D-NY)  
Dan Lungren (R-CA)  
Connie Mack (R-FL)  
Edward Madigan (R-IL)  
Ron Marlenee (R-MT)  
Dan Marriott (R-UT)  
David Martin (R-NY)  
James Martin (R-NC)  
Lynn Martin (R-IL)  
John McCain (R-AZ)  
Al McCandless (R-CA)  
Bill McCollum (R-FL)  
Joe McDade (R-PA)  
Bob McEwen (R-OH)  
Raymond McGrath (R-NY)  
John McKernan (R-ME)  
Stewart McKinney (R-CT)  
Dan Mica (D-FL)  
Bob Michel (R-IL)  
Barbara Mikulski (D-MD)  
Clarence Miller (R-OH)  
Guy Molinari (R-NY)  
Sonny Montgomery (D-MS)  
Carlos Moorhead (R-CA)  
Sid Morrison (R-WA)  
John Myers (R-IN)  
William Natcher (D-KY)  
Bill Nichols (D-AL)  
Howard Nielson (R-UT)  
James Oberstar (D-MN)  
George O'Brien (R-IL)  
Michael Oxley (R-OH)  
Ron Packard (R-CA)  
Stan Parris (R-VA)  
Chip Pashayan (R-CA)  
Bill Patman (D-TX)  
Ron Paul (R-TX)  
Carl Perkins (D-KY)  
John Porter (R-IL)  
Carl Pursell (R-MI)  
Ralph Regula (R-OH)  
Bill Richardson (D-NM)  
Tom Ridge (R-PA)  
Matthew Rinaldo (R-NJ)  
Don Ritter (R-PA)  
Pat Roberts (R-KS)  
Kenneth Robinson (R-VA)  
Buddy Roemer (D-LA)  
Harold Rogers (R-KY)  
Toby Roth (R-WI)  
Roy Rowland (D-GA)  
Eldon Rudd (R-AZ)  
Harold Sawyer (R-MI)  
Dan Schaefer (R-CO)  
Claudine Schneider (R-RI)  
Pat Schroeder (D-CO)  
Richard Schulze (R-PA)  
James Sensenbrenner (R-WI)  
Clay Shaw (R-FL)  
Richard Shelby (D-AL)  
Norman Shumway (R-CA)  
Bud Shuster (R-PA)  
Mark Siljander (R-MI)  
Joe Skeen (R-NM)  
Ike Skelton (D-MO)  
Bob Smith (R-OR)  
Chris Smith (R-NJ)  
Denny Smith (R-OR)  
Neal Smith (D-IA)  
Virginia Smith (R-NE)  
Olympia Snowe (R-ME)  
Gene Snyder (R-KY)  
Gerald Solomon (R-NY)  
Floyd Spence (R-SC)  
Arlan Stangeland (R-MN)  
Charlie Stenholm (D-TX)  
Bob Stump (R-AZ)  
Mike Synar (D-OK)  
Robin Tallon (D-SC)  
Tom Tauke (R-IA)  
Billy Tauzin (D-LA)  
Gene Taylor (R-MO)  
Bill Thomas (R-CA)  
Lindsay Thomas (D-GA)  
Tom Vandergriff (D-TX)  
Barbara Vucanovich (R-NV)  
Robert Walker (R-PA)  
Wes Watkins (D-OK)  
James Weaver (D-OR)  
Vin Weber (R-MN)  
William Whitehurst (R-VA)  
Bob Whittaker (R-KS)  
Jamie Whitten (D-MS)  
Lyle Williams (R-OH)  
Larry Winn (R-KS)  
Frank Wolf (R-VA)  
George Wortley (R-NY)  
Ron Wyden (D-OR)  
Bill Young (R-FL)  
Bob Young (D-MO)  
Don Young (R-AK)  
Ed Zschau (R-CA)  

Did Not Vote:

William Clay (D-MO)  
Cardiss Collins (D-IL)  
Byron Dorgan (D-ND)  
Wayne Dowdy (D-MS)  
Mervyn Dymally (D-CA)  
Kent Hance (D-TX)  
James Hansen (R-UT)  
Augustus Hawkins (D-CA)  
Ed Jenkins (D-GA)  
Jack Kemp (R-NY)  
Jim Leach (R-IA)  
Jerry Lewis (R-CA)  
Joel Pritchard (R-WA)  
Richard Ray (D-GA)  
Paul Simon (D-IL)  
Steven Solarz (D-NY)  

Voting data shown on this page comes from Voteview.