RightDataUSA


Vote Data for HR3917 (96th Congress)


Date: July 19, 1979

Subject: Health "Planning" Agencies

Description: Preyer (D-NC) amendment to the Satterfield (D-VA) amendment, to require state health planning agencies to receive comment on and publish their criteria for reviewing certificate-of-need applications for approval of medical service changes and to prohibit any conditional approvals that do not conform to the published review criteria. The Satterfield measure is a step in the right direction toward clamping down on the "health planning" bureaucracy, which adds to health care costs while often impeding the delivery of modern health care through excessive regualtion. The Preyer amendment would have limited the power of the Satterfield amendment in controlling these bureaucracies.

Result: Amendment Rejected, 203-211

Names ordered: By yea/nay       Order alphabetically       Order by party       Order by state

Click on a Representative's name to see more information for that Representative.

Voted in Favor:

Joseph Addabbo (D-NY)  
Daniel Akaka (D-HI)  
Bill Alexander (D-AR)  
Glenn Anderson (D-CA)  
Ike Andrews (D-NC)  
Frank Annunzio (D-IL)  
Beryl Anthony (D-AR)  
Thomas Ashley (D-OH)  
Les Aspin (D-WI)  
Les AuCoin (D-OR)  
Don Bailey (D-PA)  
Alvin Baldus (D-WI)  
Michael Barnes (D-MD)  
Edward Beard (D-RI)  
Berkley Bedell (D-IA)  
Tony Beilenson (D-CA)  
Charles Bennett (D-FL)  
Doug Bereuter (R-NE)  
Mario Biaggi (D-NY)  
Jonathan Bingham (D-NY)  
James Blanchard (D-MI)  
Lindy Boggs (D-LA)  
Edward Boland (D-MA)  
David Bonior (D-MI)  
Don Bonker (D-WA)  
John Brademas (D-IN)  
Jack Brooks (D-TX)  
George Brown (D-CA)  
Bill Burlison (D-MO)  
John Burton (D-CA)  
Phillip Burton (D-CA)  
Bob Carr (D-MI)  
Tim Lee Carter (R-KY)  
John Cavanaugh (D-NE)  
Shirley Chisholm (D-NY)  
William Clay (D-MO)  
Tony Coelho (D-CA)  
Cardiss Collins (D-IL)  
Silvio Conte (R-MA)  
James Corman (D-CA)  
William Cotter (D-CT)  
George Danielson (D-CA)  
Tom Daschle (D-SD)  
Mendel Davis (D-SC)  
Ron Dellums (D-CA)  
Butler Derrick (D-SC)  
Norm Dicks (D-WA)  
Charles Diggs (D-MI)  
John Dingell (D-MI)  
Julian Dixon (D-CA)  
Brian Donnelly (D-MA)  
Thomas Downey (D-NY)  
Robert Drinan (D-MA)  
Joseph Early (D-MA)  
Bob Eckhardt (D-TX)  
Bob Edgar (D-PA)  
Don Edwards (D-CA)  
Allen Ertel (D-PA)  
David Evans (D-IN)  
John Fary (D-IL)  
Dante Fascell (D-FL)  
Vic Fazio (D-CA)  
Millicent Fenwick (R-NJ)  
Geraldine Ferraro (D-NY)  
Joseph Fisher (D-VA)  
Floyd Fithian (D-IN)  
Jim Florio (D-NJ)  
Tom Foley (D-WA)  
Harold Ford (D-TN)  
William Ford (D-MI)  
Wyche Fowler (D-GA)  
Martin Frost (D-TX)  
Robert Garcia (D-NY)  
Dick Gephardt (D-MO)  
Robert Giaimo (D-CT)  
Benjamin Gilman (R-NY)  
Henry B. Gonzalez (D-TX)  
Albert Gore, Jr. (D-TN)  
William Gray (D-PA)  
Bill Green (R-NY)  
Frank Guarini (D-NJ)  
Lamar Gudger (D-NC)  
Tony Hall (D-OH)  
Lee Hamilton (D-IN)  
James Hanley (D-NY)  
Tom Harkin (D-IA)  
Herbert Harris (D-VA)  
Augustus Hawkins (D-CA)  
Bill Hefner (D-NC)  
Cecil Heftel (D-HI)  
Ken Holland (D-SC)  
Liz Holtzman (D-NY)  
Frank Horton (R-NY)  
William Hughes (D-NJ)  
Earl Hutto (D-FL)  
Richard Ichord (D-MO)  
Andy Jacobs, Jr. (D-IN)  
John Jenrette (D-SC)  
Bizz Johnson (D-CA)  
Walter Jones (D-NC)  
Robert Kastenmeier (D-WI)  
Dale Kildee (D-MI)  
Ray Kogovsek (D-CO)  
Peter Kostmayer (D-PA)  
John LaFalce (D-NY)  
Raymond Lederer (D-PA)  
William Lehman (D-FL)  
Mickey Leland (D-TX)  
Jim Lloyd (D-CA)  
Gillis Long (D-LA)  
Mike Lowry (D-WA)  
Stan Lundine (D-NY)  
Andrew Maguire (D-NJ)  
Ed Markey (D-MA)  
Marc Marks (R-PA)  
Robert Matsui (D-CA)  
Jim Mattox (D-TX)  
Nicholas Mavroules (D-MA)  
Mike McCormack (D-WA)  
Matthew McHugh (D-NY)  
Stewart McKinney (R-CT)  
Barbara Mikulski (D-MD)  
Abner Mikva (D-IL)  
George Miller (D-CA)  
Norman Mineta (D-CA)  
Joseph Minish (D-NJ)  
Parren Mitchell (D-MD)  
Joe Moakley (D-MA)  
Toby Moffett (D-CT)  
William Moorhead (D-PA)  
Ronald Mottl (D-OH)  
Morgan Murphy (D-IL)  
Ozzie Myers (D-PA)  
Steven Neal (D-NC)  
Lucien Nedzi (D-MI)  
Richard Nolan (D-MN)  
Henry Nowak (D-NY)  
Mary Rose Oakar (D-OH)  
James Oberstar (D-MN)  
David Obey (D-WI)  
Richard Ottinger (D-NY)  
Jerry Patterson (D-CA)  
Don Pease (D-OH)  
Claude Pepper (D-FL)  
Carl Perkins (D-KY)  
Peter Peyser (D-NY)  
Richardson Preyer (D-NC)  
Melvin Price (D-IL)  
Charles Rangel (D-NY)  
William Ratchford (D-CT)  
Henry Reuss (D-WI)  
Fred Richmond (D-NY)  
Peter Rodino (D-NJ)  
Charlie Rose (D-NC)  
Benjamin Rosenthal (D-NY)  
Dan Rostenkowski (D-IL)  
Edward Roybal (D-CA)  
Marty Russo (D-IL)  
Martin Sabo (D-MN)  
Jim Santini (D-NV)  
James Scheuer (D-NY)  
Pat Schroeder (D-CO)  
John Seiberling (D-OH)  
James Shannon (D-MA)  
Phil Sharp (D-IN)  
Paul Simon (D-IL)  
Olympia Snowe (R-ME)  
Steven Solarz (D-NY)  
Gladys Noon Spellman (D-MD)  
Edward Stack (D-FL)  
Harley Staggers (D-WV)  
Pete Stark (D-CA)  
Tom Steed (D-OK)  
Bennett Stewart (D-IL)  
Fernand St. Germain (D-RI)  
Louis Stokes (D-OH)  
Gerry Studds (D-MA)  
Al Swift (D-WA)  
Mike Synar (D-OK)  
Frank Thompson (D-NJ)  
Bob Traxler (D-MI)  
Morris Udall (D-AZ)  
Al Ullman (D-OR)  
Lionel Van Deerlin (D-CA)  
Charles Vanik (D-OH)  
Bruce Vento (D-MN)  
Doug Walgren (D-PA)  
Henry Waxman (D-CA)  
James Weaver (D-OR)  
Ted Weiss (D-NY)  
Charlie Whitley (D-NC)  
Pat Williams (D-MT)  
Bob Wilson (R-CA)  
Charles Wilson (D-CA)  
Charlie Wilson (D-TX)  
Tim Wirth (D-CO)  
Lester Wolff (D-NY)  
Howard Wolpe (D-MI)  
Jim Wright (D-TX)  
Sidney Yates (D-IL)  
Bob Young (D-MO)  
Clement Zablocki (D-WI)  
Leo Zeferetti (D-NY)  

Voted Against:

James Abdnor (R-SD)  
Don Albosta (D-MI)  
Jerome Ambro (D-NY)  
Mark Andrews (R-ND)  
Doug Applegate (D-OH)  
Bill Archer (R-TX)  
John Ashbrook (R-OH)  
Eugene Atkinson (D-PA)  
Robert Badham (R-CA)  
Skip Bafalis (R-FL)  
Doug Barnard (D-GA)  
Robert Bauman (R-MD)  
Robin Beard (R-TN)  
Adam Benjamin (D-IN)  
Ed Bethune (R-AR)  
Tom Bevill (D-AL)  
Bill Boner (D-TN)  
David Bowen (D-MS)  
John Breaux (D-LA)  
Jack Brinkley (D-GA)  
William Broomfield (R-MI)  
Clarence Brown, Jr. (R-OH)  
Jim Broyhill (R-NC)  
John Buchanan (R-AL)  
Clair Burgener (R-CA)  
Caldwell Butler (R-VA)  
Beverly Byron (D-MD)  
Carroll Campbell (R-SC)  
William Carney (R-NY)  
Bill Chappell (D-FL)  
Dick Cheney (R-WY)  
Don Clausen (R-CA)  
James Cleveland (R-NH)  
Bill Clinger (R-PA)  
James Collins (R-TX)  
Barber Conable (R-NY)  
Tom Corcoran (R-IL)  
Jim Courter (R-NJ)  
Daniel Crane (R-IL)  
Phil Crane (R-IL)  
Norman D'Amours (D-NH)  
Dan Daniel (D-VA)  
Robert Daniel (R-VA)  
William Dannemeyer (R-CA)  
Robert Davis (R-MI)  
Joel Deckard (R-IN)  
Kika de la Garza (D-TX)  
Edward Derwinski (R-IL)  
Samuel Devine (R-OH)  
Bill Dickinson (R-AL)  
Bob Dornan (R-CA)  
Charles Dougherty (R-PA)  
John Duncan (R-TN)  
Robert Duncan (D-OR)  
Jack Edwards (R-AL)  
Glenn English (D-OK)  
Arlen Erdahl (R-MN)  
John Erlenborn (R-IL)  
Billy Lee Evans (D-GA)  
Thomas Evans (R-DE)  
Paul Findley (R-IL)  
Ronnie Flippo (D-AL)  
L.H. Fountain (D-NC)  
Bill Frenzel (R-MN)  
Don Fuqua (D-FL)  
Joe Gaydos (D-PA)  
Newt Gingrich (R-GA)  
Bo Ginn (D-GA)  
Dan Glickman (D-KS)  
Barry Goldwater, Jr. (R-CA)  
Bill Goodling (R-PA)  
Bill Gradison (R-OH)  
Phil Gramm (D-TX)  
Charles Grassley (R-IA)  
Wayne Grisham (R-CA)  
Tennyson Guyer (R-OH)  
Tom Hagedorn (R-MN)  
Sam Hall (D-TX)  
J.P. Hammerschmidt (R-AR)  
Kent Hance (D-TX)  
George Hansen (R-ID)  
William Harsha (R-OH)  
Margaret Heckler (R-MA)  
Jack Hightower (D-TX)  
Elwood Hillis (R-IN)  
Jon Hinson (R-MS)  
Harold Hollenbeck (R-NJ)  
Marjorie Holt (R-MD)  
Larry Hopkins (R-KY)  
James Howard (D-NJ)  
Carroll Hubbard (D-KY)  
Henry Hyde (R-IL)  
Jim Jeffords (R-VT)  
Jim Jeffries (R-KS)  
Ed Jenkins (D-GA)  
Jim Johnson (R-CO)  
Jim Jones (D-OK)  
Abraham Kazen (D-TX)  
Richard Kelly (R-FL)  
Jack Kemp (R-NY)  
Thomas Kindness (R-OH)  
Ken Kramer (R-CO)  
Robert Lagomarsino (R-CA)  
Delbert Latta (R-OH)  
Buddy Leach (D-LA)  
Marvin Leath (D-TX)  
Gary Lee (R-NY)  
Norman Lent (R-NY)  
Elliott Levitas (D-GA)  
Jerry Lewis (R-CA)  
Bob Livingston (R-LA)  
Marilyn Lloyd (D-TN)  
Tom Loeffler (R-TX)  
Clarence Long (D-MD)  
Trent Lott (R-MS)  
Manuel Lujan (R-NM)  
Dan Lungren (R-CA)  
Edward Madigan (R-IL)  
Ron Marlenee (R-MT)  
James Martin (R-NC)  
Dawson Mathis (D-GA)  
Romano Mazzoli (D-KY)  
Pete McCloskey (R-CA)  
Robert McClory (R-IL)  
Joe McDade (R-PA)  
Larry McDonald (D-GA)  
Robert McEwen (R-NY)  
Gunn McKay (D-UT)  
Dan Mica (D-FL)  
Bob Michel (R-IL)  
Clarence Miller (R-OH)  
Donald Mitchell (R-NY)  
Robert Mollohan (D-WV)  
Sonny Montgomery (D-MS)  
Henson Moore (R-LA)  
Carlos Moorhead (R-CA)  
Austin Murphy (D-PA)  
John Murphy (D-NY)  
John Murtha (D-PA)  
John Myers (R-IN)  
William Natcher (D-KY)  
Bill Nelson (D-FL)  
Bill Nichols (D-AL)  
George O'Brien (R-IL)  
Leon Panetta (D-CA)  
Chip Pashayan (R-CA)  
Edward Patten (D-NJ)  
Ron Paul (R-TX)  
Tom Petri (R-WI)  
Jake Pickle (D-TX)  
Joel Pritchard (R-WA)  
Carl Pursell (R-MI)  
Dan Quayle (R-IN)  
Jimmy Quillen (R-TN)  
Nick Rahall (D-WV)  
Tom Railsback (R-IL)  
Ralph Regula (R-OH)  
John Rhodes (R-AZ)  
Matthew Rinaldo (R-NJ)  
Ray Roberts (D-TX)  
Kenneth Robinson (R-VA)  
Robert Roe (D-NJ)  
Toby Roth (R-WI)  
John Rousselot (R-CA)  
Bill Royer (R-CA)  
Eldon Rudd (R-AZ)  
Harold Runnels (D-NM)  
David Satterfield (D-VA)  
Harold Sawyer (R-MI)  
Richard Schulze (R-PA)  
Keith Sebelius (R-KS)  
James Sensenbrenner (R-WI)  
Richard Shelby (D-AL)  
Norman Shumway (R-CA)  
Bud Shuster (R-PA)  
Ike Skelton (D-MO)  
John Slack (D-WV)  
Neal Smith (D-IA)  
Virginia Smith (R-NE)  
Gene Snyder (R-KY)  
Gerald Solomon (R-NY)  
Floyd Spence (R-SC)  
Arlan Stangeland (R-MN)  
William Stanton (R-OH)  
Charlie Stenholm (D-TX)  
Dave Stockman (R-MI)  
Samuel Stratton (D-NY)  
Bob Stump (D-AZ)  
Steven Symms (R-ID)  
Tom Tauke (R-IA)  
Gene Taylor (R-MO)  
Bill Thomas (R-CA)  
David Treen (R-LA)  
Paul Trible (R-VA)  
Guy Vander Jagt (R-MI)  
Harold Volkmer (D-MO)  
Robert Walker (R-PA)  
William Wampler (R-VA)  
Wes Watkins (D-OK)  
Richard White (D-TX)  
William Whitehurst (R-VA)  
Bob Whittaker (R-KS)  
Jamie Whitten (D-MS)  
Lyle Williams (R-OH)  
Larry Winn (R-KS)  
Joe Wyatt (D-TX)  
John Wydler (R-NY)  
Chalmers Wylie (R-OH)  
Gus Yatron (D-PA)  
Bill Young (R-FL)  
Don Young (R-AK)  

Did Not Vote:

John Anderson (R-IL)  
Richard Bolling (D-MO)  
William Brodhead (D-MI)  
Tom Coleman (R-MO)  
John Conyers (D-MI)  
Lawrence Coughlin (R-PA)  
Christopher Dodd (D-CT)  
Mickey Edwards (R-OK)  
David Emery (R-ME)  
Hamilton Fish, Jr. (R-NY)  
Daniel Flood (D-PA)  
Edwin Forsythe (R-NJ)  
Sam Gibbons (D-FL)  
Jerry Huckaby (D-LA)  
Andy Ireland (D-FL)  
Ed Jones (D-TN)  
Jim Leach (R-IA)  
Thomas Luken (D-OH)  
Dan Marriott (R-UT)  
Don Ritter (R-PA)  

Voting data shown on this page comes from Voteview.